Measuring Law Students’ Attitudes Towards and Experiences of Clinical Legal Education at The University of Hong Kong

Claudia Man-yiu Tam

Abstract


As law schools in Hong Kong begin to integrate experiential learning into their educational models, clinical legal education (CLE) has symbiotically gained traction as an effective way for students to apply their legal knowledge in a skills-based and client-centered environment. This empirical study is the first of its kind to evaluate the impacts of CLE at The University of Hong Kong (HKU) over the past ten years, by analyzing the survey responses provided by 125 law students regarding their attitudes towards and experiences of CLE. The article traces the birth and development of CLE at HKU, turning first to its theoretical basis to make the case for its importance, and placing emphasis on the ability of CLE’s teaching-service pedagogy to alleviate the public interest law deficit and supplement passive learning as an engaging instructional method in the Hong Kong context. The survey results are then discussed in light of the doctrinal analysis to illustrate that clinic and non-clinic students alike are generally satisfied that HKU’s CLE program has achieved its skills, cognitive, and civic aims, and notably, that clinic students had a statistically significant higher intention to participate in pro bono work after graduation than non-clinic students or students engaged in volunteering.         


Full Text:

XML PDF

References


— — ‘Free Legal Advice Scheme on HKU Campus’ (Free Legal Advice Scheme on HKU Campus, Faculty of Law, The University of Hong Kong) accessed 24 March 2019.

— — ‘The Joint Pro Bono Protocol for Legal Work’ (The Law Society) accessed 25 March 2019.

— — ‘HKU-HKRAC Clinical Legal Education Programme’ (Human Rights Portal) accessed 24 March 2019.

— — ‘HKU’s Live-Client Clinical Legal Education (“CLE”) Programme’ (Hong Kong Lawyer, November 2015) accessed 24 March 2019.

— — ‘LLAW3148 Clinical Legal Education’ accessed 25 March 2019.

— — ‘LLAW3222 Human Rights in Practice’ accessed 24 March 2019.

— — ‘LLAW3246 Disability rights clinic’ accessed 24 March 2019.

— — ‘LLAW3252 The Global Migration Legal Clinic’ accessed 24 March 2019.

— — ‘Scheme Poster (January 2019 semester)’ (Free Legal Advice Scheme on HKU Campus, Faculty of Law, The University of Hong Kong) accessed 24 March 2019.

— — ‘Volunteering’ (NCVO) accessed 25 March 2019.

Adewumi A A and Bamgbose O A, ‘Attitude of Students to Clinical Legal Education: A Case Study of Faculty of Law, University of Ibadan’ (2016) 3 Asian Journal of Legal Education 106

Amsterdam A G, ‘Clinical Legal Education - A 21st Century Perspective’ (1984) 34 Journal of Legal Education 612

Ashar S, ‘Law Clinics and Collective Mobilization’ (2008) 14 Clinical Law Review 355

Barnhizer D, ‘The University Ideal and Clinical Legal Education’ (1990) 35 New York Law School Law Review 87

Barry M M, Camp A R, Johnson M E and others, ‘Teaching Social Justice Lawyering: Systematically Including Community Legal Education in Law School Clinics’ (2012) 18 Clinical Law Review 401

Bellow G and Johnson E, ‘Reflections on the University of Southern California Clinical Semester’ (1971) 44 Southern California Law Review 664

Bloch F (ed), The Global Clinical Movement: Educating Lawyers for Social Justice (OUP 2011)

Caplow S, ‘Clinical Legal Education in Hong Kong: A Time to Move Forward’ (2006) 36 Hong Kong Law Journal 229

Evans A, Cody A, Copeland A and others, Australian clinical legal education: Designing and operating a best practice clinical program in an Australian law school (ANU Press 2017)

Granfield R, ‘Institutionalizing Public Service in Law School: Results on the Impact of Mandatory Pro Bono Programs’ (2007) 54 Buffalo Law Review 1355

Grossman G S, ‘Clinical Legal Education: History and Diagnosis’ (1973) 26 Journal of Legal Education 162

Krieger S H, ‘The Effect of Clinical Education on Law Student Reasoning: An Empirical Study’ (2008) 35 William Mitchell Law Review 359

Lesnick H, ‘Why Pro Bono in Law Schools’ (1994) 13 Law & Inequality: A Journal of Theory and Practice 25

Marsh L and Ramsden M, ‘Fostering Civic Engagement in Legal Education: Observations from Hong Kong’ (2014) 1 Asian Journal of Legal Education 1

— — ‘Developments in Hong Kong Legal Education’ (2016) 3 Asian Journal of Legal Education 2

McKeown P, ‘Law student attitudes towards pro bono and voluntary work: The experience at Northumbria University’ (2015) 22 International Journal of Clinical Legal Education 6

Milstein E S, ‘Clinical Legal Education in the United States: In-House Clinics, Externships, and Simulations’ (2001) 51 Journal of Legal Education 375

Nulty D D, ‘The adequacy of response rates to online and paper surveys: what can be done?’ (2008) 33 Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education 301

Pincus W, ‘The Clinical Component in University Professional Education’ (1971) 32 Ohio State Law Journal 283

Redlich N, ‘Moral Value of Clinical Legal Education: A Reply’ (1983) 33 The Journal of Legal Education 613

Rhode D L, ‘Cultures of Commitment: Pro Bono for Lawyers and Law Students’ (1999) 67 Fordham Law Review 2415

Sandefur R and Selbin J, ‘The Clinic Effect’ (2009) 16 Clinical Law Review 57

Seielstad A M, ‘Community Building as a Means of Teaching Creative, Cooperative, and Complex Problem Solving in Clinical Legal Education’ (2002) 8 Clinical Law Review 445

Shanahan C F, Selbin J, Mark A and others, ‘Measuring Law School Clinics’ (2018) 92 Tulane Law Review 547

Skrodzka M, Chia J, and Bruce-Jones E, ‘The Next Step Forward - The Development of Clinical Legal Education in Poland through a Clinical Pilot Program in Bialystok’ (2008) 2 Columbia Journal of East European Law 56

Spiegel M, ‘Theory and Practice in Legal Education: An Essay on Clinical Education’ (1987) 34 UCLA Law Review 577

Sullivan W M, Colby A, Welch J and others, Educating Lawyers: Preparation for the Profession of Law (Jossey-Bass 2007) 191

The Steering Committee on the Review of Legal Education and Training in Hong Kong, Report on Legal Education and Training in Hong Kong: Preliminary Review (The Law Society of Hong Kong 2001) accessed 24 March 2019

Wilson R J, ‘Training for Justice: The Global Reach of Clinical Legal Education’ (2004) 22 Penn State International Law Review 421

— — The Global Evolution of Clinical Legal Education: More than a Method (CUP 2017) 93-94

Wizner S and Curtis D, ‘Here's What We Do: Some Notes about Clinical Legal Education’ (1980) 29 Cleveland State Law Review 673




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.19164/ijcle.v27i1.890

Copyright (c) 2020 Claudia Man-yiu Tam

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

ISSN 1467-1069
ESSN 2056-3930