Smashing the Binary? A new era of legal gender registration in the Yogyakarta Principles Plus 10
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.19164/ijgsl.v1i1.1001Abstract
This article analyses the potential of Principle 31 of the Yogyakarta Principles plus 10 to smash the gender binary. Principle 31 proposes several innovations with regards to the registration of people’s gender on official documents and/or in state registries. In order to understand the practical meanings of these innovations, the article inspects exemplary jurisdictions that have realised some of the Principle’s suggestions. Queer and feminist theories serve as the normative framework to understand how Principle 31 smashes the static binary gender registration in the form of F and M. Moreover, relying on developments in international law helps to comprehend the context in which Principle 31 was created and its innovative nature. The four central reforms proposed by Principle 31 are discussed in independent sections in the article. They include the elimination of gender markers, unconditional gender recognition laws, the introduction of non-binary legal gender categories and the elimination of the public gender registration. The article concludes that all of these four measures face specific limitations in how they smash the gender binary, but, as a whole, they trouble the naturalised understanding of dichotomous (legal) gender relations. Finally, Principle 31 alerts to the necessity of reducing the naturalised state control over people’s gender assignment, while making sure that where the state (still) has control, it valorises gender diversity outside of a binary frame.References
Althoff, N., Schabram, G. and Follmar Otto, P. (2017). Gutachten. Geschlechtervielfalt im Recht. Status quo und Entwicklung von Regelungsmodellen zur Anerkennung und zum Schutz von Geschlechtervielfalt. Deutsches Institute für Menschenrechte.
Arístegui, I., Radusky, P.D., Zalazar, V., Romero, M., Schwartz, J. and Sued, O. (2017). Impact of the Gender Identity Law in Argentinean transgender women. International Journal of Transgenderism 18, 446–456.
Australian Government, 2013. Australian Government Guidelines on the Recognition of Sex and Gender.
Aziz, A. and Azhar, S. (2019). Social Exclusion and Official Recognition for Hijra in Bangladesh. Journal of Research on Women and Gender 9, 3–19.
Bennett, T. (2014). No Man’s Land: Non-Binary Sex Identification in Australian Law and Policy. UNSW Law Journal 37, 847.
Browne, K. (2016). Queer Quantification or Queer(y)ing Quantification: Creting Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual or Heterosexual Citizens through Governmental Social Research, in: Nash, C.J., Browne, K. (Eds.), Queer Methods and Methodologies: Intersecting Queer Theories and Social Science Research. Routledge, pp. 229–249.
Büchler, A. and Cottier, M. (2005). Intersexualität, Transsexualität und das Recht, in: Degele, N., Brand, R. (Eds.), Queering gender - queering society. Freiburger FrauenStudien. Fritz, Freiburg i.Br, pp. 115–140.
Butler, J. (2007). Gender trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. Routledge, New York London.
Butler, J. (2004). Undoing Gender. Routledge, New York.
Butler, J. (1994). Contingent Foundations: Feminism and the Question of “Postmodernism,” in: Benhabib, S., Butler, J., Cornell, D., Fraser, N. (Eds.), Feminist Contentions: A Philosophical Exchange. Routledge, New York, pp. 3–21.
Calleja, G. (2018), Interview.
Carpenter, M. (2018). The “Normalisation” of Intersex Bodies and “Othering” of Intersex Identities, in: Scherpe, J., Dutta, A., Helms, T. (Eds.), The Legal Status of Intersex Persons. Intersentia, Cambridge, Antwerpe, Portland, pp. 445–514.
Chiam, Z., Duffy, S. and González Gil, M. (2017). Trans Legal Mapping Report: Recognition before the law. 2nd edition. ILGA World, Geneva.
Chumley, C. (2016). Transgender madness is about destroying family. WND. Available at: https://www.wnd.com/2016/05/transgender-madness-is-about-destroying-family/ [Last accessed 13 March 2020].
Clarke, J.A. (2019). They, Them, and Theirs. Harvard Law Review 132.
Cooper, D. and Renz, F. (2016). If the State Decertified Gender, What Might Happen to its Meaning and Value? Journal of Law and Society 43, 483–505.
Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, (2015). Human rights and intersex people.
Daily Nation, (2018). Argentine man changes gender to retire early. Available at: https://www.nation.co.ke/news/world/Argentine-legally-changes-gender-to-retire-early/1068-4352176-6iecp2z/index.html [Last accessed 13 March 2020]
Dunne, P. and Hewitt, T. (2018). Gender recognition self-determination and segregated space. Oxford Human Rights Hub. Available at: http://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/gender-recognition-self-determination-and-segregated-space/ [Last accessed 13 March 2020].
The Guardian, (2018). The Guardian view on the Gender Recognition Act: where rights collide. Editorial. Available at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/oct/17/the-guardian-view-on-the-gender-recognition-act-where-rights-collide [Last accessed 13 March 2020].
Faget, D. (2019). Court upholds “sterilization” rule for gender change. Japan Today. Available at: https://japantoday.com/category/national/japan-court-upholds-'sterilisation'-rule-for-gender-change [Last accessed 13 March 2020].
Feder, J.L. (2015). U.S. Has No Process For Accepting Transgender Passports, State Department Confirms. BuzzFeed. Available at: https://www.buzzfeed.com/lesterfeder/us-cant-process-transgender-passports-state-department-confi [Last accessed 13 March 2020].
Garland, J. (2015). The Legal Status of Transsexual and Transgender Persons in Sweden, in: Scherpe, J.M. (Ed.), The Legal Status of Transsexual and Transgender Persons. Intersentia, Antwerp.
German Ethics Council, (2013). Intersexuality. Opinion. Berlin.
Ghattas, D.C., Unmüßig, B. and Mittag, J. (2013). Human rights between the sexes: a preliminary study on the life situations of inter*individuals. Heinrich-Böll-Stift, Berlin.
Gössl, S. (2013). Intersexuelle Menschen im Internationalen Privatrecht. StAZ - Das Standesamt, Zeitschrift für Standesamtswesen, Familienrecht, Staatsangehörigkeitsrecht, Personenstandsrechts, internationales Privatrecht des In- und Auslands 301–305.
Gössl, S.L. and Völzmann, B. (2019). Legal Gender Beyond the Binary. International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 33, 403–429.
Hashim, A. (2018). Pakistan passes landmark transgender rights law. Aljazeera. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/05/pakistan-passes-landmark-transgender-rights-law-180509095207950.html [Last accessed 13 March 2020].
HM Passport Office, (2014). Gender Marking in Passports: Internal Review of Existing Arrangements and Possible Future Options.
Hollimon, S.E. (2015). Native American Two Spirits, in: The International Encyclopedia of Human Sexuality. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Holzer, L. (2019). Sexually Dimorphic Bodies: A Production of Birth Certificates. Australian Feminist Law Journal 45, 91–110.
Holzer, L. (2018). Non-Binary Gender Registration Models in Europe. Report on third gender marker or no gender marker options (Working Paper). ILGA-Europe.
Hossain, A. (2017). The paradox of recognition: hijra, third gender and sexual rights in Bangladesh. Culture, Health & Sexuality 19, 1–14.
International Civil Aviation Organization, (2015). Machine Readable Travel Documents. Part 4 — Specifications for Machine Readable Passports (MRPs) and other TD3 Size MRTDs (No. Doc 9303), Seventh edition.
International Civil Aviation Organization, 2012. A Review of the Requirement to Display the Holder’s Gender on Travel Document (No. TAG/MRTD/21-IP/4 20/11/12). ICAO.
James, S.E., Herman, J.L., Rankin, S., Keisling, M., Mottet, L. and Anafi, M. (2016). The Report of the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey. National Center for Trangender Equality, Washington, DC.
Kapur, R. (2018). Gender, Alterity and Human Rights: Freedom in a Fishbowl. Edward Elgar Pub, Northampton, MA.
Knight, K., 2015. Nepal’s Third Gender Passport Blazes Trails. Human Rights Watch. Available at https://www.hrw.org/news/2015/10/26/nepals-third-gender-passport-blazes-trails [Last accessed 5 March 2020].
Lembke, U. (2011). Zur Situation von Menschen mit Intersexualität in Deutschland. Opinion expressed in the German Ethics Council’s expert consultation.
Lorber, J. (2000). Using gender to undo gender: A feminist degendering movement. Feminist theory 1, 79–95.
Lorber, J. (1996). Beyond the Binaries: Depolarizing the Categories of Sex, Sexuality, and Gender*. Sociological Inquiry 66, 143–160.
Madrigal-Borloz, V. (2018). Protection against violence and discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity (No. A/73/152).
Mayday4Women, (2018). Women’s Mass Resignation from Labour. Available at: https://www.mayday4women.com/2018/05/01/womens-mass-resignation-labour/ [Last accessed 3 march 2020].
Ministerie van Veiligheid en Justitie, (2016). Government opts for less registration of gender. Available at: https://www.government.nl/latest/news/2016/12/23/government-opts-for-less-registration-of-gender [Last accessed 3 March 2020].
Ministry of Government and Consumer Services, (2016). Gender on Health Cards and Driver’s Licences. Available at: https://news.ontario.ca/mgs/en/2016/06/gender-on-health-cards-and-drivers-licences.html [Last accessed 3 March 2020].
Neuman Wipfler, A.J. (2016). Identity Crisis: The Limitations of Expanding Government Recognition of Gender Identity and the Possibility of Genderless Identity Documents. Harvard Journal of Law and Gender 491–554.
Nisar, M.A. (2018). (Un)Becoming a Man: Legal Consciousness of the Third Gender Category in Pakistan. Gender & Society 32, 59–81.
Omi, M., Winant, H. (2014). Racial Formation in the United States. Routledge.
Otto, D. (2015). Queering Gender [Identity] in International Law. Nordic Journal of Human Rights 33, 299–318.
Pace, Y. (2017). Malta introduces ‘X’ marker on passports, ID cards and work permits. MaltaToday. Available at: http://www.maltatoday.com.mt/news/national/80228/malta_introduces_x_marker_on_passports_id_cards_and_work_permits [Last accessed 3 March 2020].
SafeTravelsMagazine, (2018). Travel Advisory Tweet >> Intersex/unspecified gender on your passport? You won’t be allowed in to the UAE, plus more entry and exit info. Safe Travels Magazine. Available at: http://www.safetravelsmagazine.com/2018/03/07/travel-advisory-tweet-intersex-unspecified-gender-on-your-passport-you-wont-be-allowed-in-to-the-uae-plus-more-entry-and-exit-info/ [Last accessed 3 March 2020].
Schilt, K., Bratter, J. (2015). From Multiracial to Transgender? Assessing Attitudes toward Expanding Gender Options on the US Census. TSQ 2, 77–100.
Sharpe, A. (2018). What would changes to the Gender Recognition Act mean? Two legal views. The Conversation. Available at: http://theconversation.com/what-would-changes-to-the-gender-recognition-act-mean-two-legal-views-103204 [Last accessed 3 March 2020].
Simpson, J. (2018). Argentina issued first gender-neutral birth certificate. Political Lore. Available at: http://www.politicallore.com/argentina-issued-first-gender-neutral-birth-certificate/18119 [Last accessed 3 March 2020].
Spivak, G.C. (1990). The Post-colonial Critic: Interviews, Strategies, Dialogues. Psychology Press.
Swiss National Advisory Commission on Biomedical Ethics, (2012). On the management of differences of sex development. Ethical issues relating to "intersexuality". Opinion No. 20/2012.
TGEU, (2018). TGEU Position paper on Gender Markers. Available at: https://tgeu.org/tgeu-position-paper-on-gender-markers/ [Last accessed 3 March 2020].
FRA, The European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, (2015). The fundamental rights situation of intersex people (FRA Focus).
The Yogyakarta Principles plus 10. Additional Principles and State Obligations on the Application of International Human Rights Law in Relation to Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity, Gender Expression and Sex Characteristics to Complement the Yogyakarta Principles, (2017).
The Yogyakarta Principles, Principles on the Application of International Human Rights Law in Relation to Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity, (2007).
Third International Intersex Forum, (2013). Malta Declaration.
Thoreson, R.R. (2009). Queering Human Rights: The Yogyakarta Principles and the Norm That Dare Not Speak Its Name. Journal of Human Rights 8, 323–339.
Thoreson, R.R. (2016). Shut out: restrictions on bathroom and locker room access for transgender youth in US schools. Human Rights Watch, New York.
Transrespect, (n.d.) Legal Gender Recognition: Change of gender. TvT. Available at: http://transrespect.org/en/map/pathologization-requirement/ [Last accessed 3 March 2020].
Valentine, V. (2015). Non-binary people’s experiences in the UK. Scottish Trans Alliance, Equality Network.
Van den Brink, M., Reuß, P. and Tigchelaar, J. (2015). Out of the box? Domestic and private international law aspects of gender registration: a comparative analysis of Germany and the Netherlands. European Journal of Law Reform 17, 282–293.
Van den Brink and M., Snaathorst, D. (2017). Doing Gender Identity Justice. Evaluation Three Years Transgender Legislation in the Netherlands. 2014-2017.
Van den Brink, M. and Tigchelaar, J. (2015). Gender identity and registration of sex by public authorities. European Equality Law Review 2, 29–40.
Van den Brink, M. and Tigchelaar, J. (2014). English Summary. M/F and beyond Gender registration by the state and the legal position of transgender persons. Ministerie van Veiligheid & Justitie.
Westbrook, L. and Schilt, K. (2014). Doing Gender, Determining Gender: Transgender People, Gender Panics, and the Maintenance of the Sex/Gender/Sexuality System. Gender & Society 28, 32–57.
Wieringa, S.E. (2010). Gender Variance in Asia Discursive Contestations and Legal Implications. Gender, Technology and Development 14, 143–172.
Zeffman, H. (2018). Women quit Labour over transgender row. The Times. Available at: https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/women-quit-labour-over-transgender-row-jlxpgtp0c [Last accessed 3 March 2020]
AG Stade, 51 III 13/16, 21.11.2016
BVerfG, 10.10.2017 - 1 BvR 2019/16
A.P., Garçon and Nicot v. France [2017], Applications 79885/12, 52471/13, 52596/13 (European Court for Human Rights)
Appellant’s Submissions. NSW Registrar of Births, Deaths and Marriages v. Norrie [S273 of 2013], (High Court of Australia).
Bundesministerium Inneres, 2018. BMI-VA1300/0528-III/4/b/2018. Verwaltungsangelegenheiten - Sonstige; Personenstandswesen Erkenntnis des VfGH vom 15. Juni 2018, G 77/2017-9, zu § 2 Abs. 2 Z 3 PStG 2013 - Umsetzung zu Varianten der Geschlechtsentwicklung (“3. Geschlecht”).
Bundesrat, 2018. Drucksache 429/18. Gesetzentwurf der Bundesregierung. Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Änderung der in das Geburten-register einzutragenden Angaben.
Chile, 2018. Renonce y da Protección al Derecho a la Identidad de Género.
Christine Goodwin v. The United Kingdom [2002], Application 28957/95 (European Court for Human Rights)
Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly, Resolution 2048 (2015), Discrimination against transgender people in Europe. Doc. 13742.
Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly, Resolution 2191 (2017), Promoting the human rights of and eliminating discrimination against intersex people.
Council Regulation No 2252/2004 of 13 December 2004 on standards for security features and biometrics in passports and travel documents issued by Member States, 2004.
Dutch Civil Code.
Gender Identity, and Equality and Non-Discrimination of Same-Sex Couples, 2017.
GIGESC Act, Gender Identity, Gender Expression and Sex Characteristics Act, 2015.
Gesetz zur Einführung des Rechts auf Eheschließung für Personen gleichen Geschlechts, 2017.
Ireland, Gender Recognition Act 2015.
Justice and Related Legislation (Marriage and Gender Amendments) Act 2019 (TAS), 2019.
Kimberly Nixon v. Vancouver Rape Relief Society [2007] (Supreme Court of Canada]
Legislative Council California, 2017. Senate Bill No. 179, Chapter 853.
Ley Integral Para Personas Trans, 2018.
NALSA, National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India and others, 2014.
OLG Celle, 12.05.2017 - 17 W 5/17
Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, Pakistan, 2018.
Personenstandsgesetz, 2007.
Rees v. The United Kingdom [1986], Application 9532/81 (European Court for Human Rights)
Referentenentwurf des Bundesministeriums der Justiz und für Verbraucherschutz und des Bundesministeriums des Innern, für Bau und Heimat. Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Neuregelung der Änderung des Geschlechtseintrags, 2019.
General Data Protection Regulation, Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46/EC, 2018.
Women and Equalities Committee, House of Commons, 2015. Oral evidence: Transgender Equality Inquiry, HC 390.
X v. the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia [2019], Application 29683/16 (European Court for Human Rights)
XII ZB 52/15, 2016.
Y.Y. v. Turkey [2015], Application 24209/94 (European Court for Human Rights)
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
